Variation in mating systems of salamanders: Mate guarding or territoriality?

• Neither species exhibited aggressive behavior to defend a territory.
• In the presence of a female, males of E. aquatica were significantly more aggressive toward intruding males than were males of E. cirrigera.
• This is the first demonstration of mate-guarding behavior in a plethodontid, the most speciose family of salamanders.
• We suggest that the ecological mechanisms involved included a shift from the ancestral mate-searching pattern exhibited by most plethodontids to monopolizing females accompanied by a shift in habitat use.

Two of the most common mating tactics in vertebrates are mate guarding and territoriality, yet much of the research on these strategies has focused on mating systems in birds, despite novel insights gained from studying less traditional systems. North American stream salamanders that comprise the Eurycea bislineata complex represent an excellent nontraditional system for comparing mating strategies because these species exhibit a continuum of male morphologies, diverse habitat associations, and various potential mating strategies. We studied two species within this complex that exhibit the extremes of this continuum, Eurycea aquatica (robust morph) and Eurycea cirrigera (slender morph). The larger head in males of E. aquatica is due to larger musculature around the jaw and may be associated with aggressive behavior. Therefore, we hypothesized that the robust morphology exhibited by males of E. aquatica provides benefits during either territorial defense or mate defense and that males of E. cirrigera would not exhibit aggression in either scenario. We found that neither species exhibited aggressive behavior to defend a territory. However, in the presence of a female, males of E. aquatica were significantly more aggressive toward intruding males than were males of E. cirrigera. Therefore, mate-guarding behavior occurs in E. aquatica, and the enlarged head of males likely aids in deterring rivals. This is the first demonstration of mate-guarding behavior in a plethodontid, the most speciose family of salamanders.