Spawning time of Atlantic herring (Clupea harengus) populations within a restricted area reflects their otolith growth at the larval stage

Larval growth from three putative populations was estimated by microstructure analysis of otoliths of four year classes of adult herring sampled over a wide spawning season (February-June) in and around an inland brackish water lake (Landvikvannet) in southern Norway during the years 2012-2015. Mean width of daily increments at distances between 20 and 170 μm from the otolith core were significantly higher in Landvik herring (peak spawning in May) compared with the two other populations, Coastal Skagerrak spring spawners (peak spawning in March-April) and Norwegian spring spawning herring (peak spawning in February-March). These population differences were observed for all studied year classes and years and highly consistent with expected temperature dependent larval growth based on timing of successive spawning events. The observed patterns imply that timing of spawning was population specific with a tendency of adult herring to spawn at the same time and under the same conditions as they hatched themselves. This was also supported by vertebral counts, which are negatively correlated with temperatures during the embryonic stage. Firstly, Landvik herring which experienced higher ambient temperature during the embryonic stage were characterised by significantly lower counts than herring from the two other populations. Secondly, daily otolith growth also tended to decrease with increasing vertebral counts within the populations. The present study signifies the importance of otolith growth history for population discrimination in herring, even within the same spawning season, and further supports the use of vertebral counts in the continuous discussion on herring population structure, assessment and management.