Comparative Analysis on the Efficiency of the Injection Laryngoplasty Technique Using Calcium Hydroxyapatite (CaHA): The Thyrohyoid Approach Versus the Cricothyroid Approach

SummaryObjectivesTemporary or permanent vocal paralysis can occur after head and neck surgery for thyroid cancer, esophageal resection, a chest operation that includes lung parenchymal resection due to a vagus or recurrent laryngeal nerve injury, and so forth. These days, the main treatment for vocal fold paralysis is the injection laryngoplasty through the cricothyroid (CT) approach. However, the CT approach is difficult in that an operator cannot see from the tip of the needle to the vocal fold. The aim of this study was to determine the efficacy of the thyrohyoid (TH) approach compared with the CT approach using calcium hydroxyapatite (CaHA) in patients with permanent unilateral vocal fold palsy.MethodsFrom March 2008 to July 2012, 68 consecutive injection laryngoplasties were performed in patients with unilateral glottic insufficiency. Percutaneous injection was performed under local anesthesia into the vocalis muscle, using disposable 25 gauge, 11 cm long spinal needles through the CT membrane or TH membrane. Of the 68 patients, videostroboscopic findings and acoustic, perceptual, and subjective evaluations were completed for 64 patients before injection and at 3 months after injection.ResultsIn the 64 patients, the CT and TH approaches were used in 30 and 34 patients, respectively. The videostroboscopic findings, acoustic and perceptual parameters (maximum phonation time, jitter, shimmer, and noise-to-harmonic ratio), and Voice Handicap Index significantly improved after the injection in both the CT and TH groups (P < 0.05).ConclusionBased on the results of this trial, injection laryngoplasty using the TH approach is an effective alternative to the CT approach, especially for the injection of CaHA in patients with permanent unilateral vocal fold palsy.