Responding to refusal of recommended cesarean section: Promoting good parenting

Consideration of what a “good parent” would do in controversial perinatal cases has been largely absent from to ethics literature. This article argues when a cesarean section is required to prevent death or serious disability for a fetus, the pregnant woman has an ethical (although not legal) obligation to undergo that procedure even when she has concerns or conflicting commitments. Further, a clinician may be justified in using persuasive counseling when there is grave harm at stake that the patient has a moral obligation to prevent. This conclusion is tested by exploring its implications in several other analogous controversial contexts.