Response to comments by Nicholas et al. (2016) on “Evidence for the biotic origin of seabed pockmarks on the Australian continental shelf”

Nicholas et al. (2016) restate the results and conclusions of their own past work and that of colleagues on the North West Shelf. Although they accept that fish may be involved in ‘pockmark’ maintenance, they do not accept that fish can initiate such features. The fluid flow theory with which they have been working therefore remains intact. However, the restatement also provides no new information and no cause to revise the conclusions of Mueller (2015). More field data is required.