Intraspecific variation in alkaloid profile of four lupine species with implications for the pea aphid probing behaviour

The alkaloid profile of white lupine Lupinus albus L. cv. 'Boros' and 'Butan', narrow-leaf lupine L. angustifolius L. cv. 'Bojar', 'Graf', 'Karo', 'Mirela', and 'Sonet', yellow lupine L. luteus L. cv. 'Dukat', 'Parys', 'Perkoz', and 'Talar', and wild species big-leaf lupine L. polyphyllus Lindl. was studied. The pea aphid Acyrthosiphon pisum Harris probing behaviour was monitored using the electrical penetration graph (EPG) technique.Four types of feeding behaviour were recognized. First, on highly acceptable L. luteus cv. 'Dukat', the total and mean duration of probing, time to reach phloem phase, and the duration of the first phloem phase were comparable to those in aphids on control plant Pisum sativum. Second, on partially acceptable L. luteus cv. 'Talar', pathway activities were slightly impeded, and the probes were more numerous and slightly shorter than on control plants. The phloem phase occurred sporadically, and feeding was terminated early after a brief period of ingestion. Third, on unpalatable but acceptable L. angustifolius cv. 'Bojar' and 'Sonet', and L. luteus cv. 'Parys' and 'Perkoz', the probes were numerous and usually epidermal. The phloem phase occurred rarely, and when it did, it was short and consisted mainly of watery salivation. Finally, on unacceptable L. albus cv. 'Boros' and 'Butan', L. angustifolius cv. 'Graf', 'Karo', 'Mirela', and L. polyphyllus, total probing time and individual probes were short and phloem phase did not occur.Eighteen alkaloids were identified: one piperidine alkaloid (ammodendrine), one indole (gramine), ten quinolizidine alkaloids (one tricyclic and nine tetracyclic compounds), and six esters. All lupine varieties that contained lupanine, its derivatives and especially their esters appeared to be unacceptable to the pea aphid, independent of the total concentration of any specific lupanine alkaloid. In contrast, sparteine and its derivatives did not seem to affect aphid probing significantly.

Graphical abstractGramine and lupanine, its derivatives and their esters are probably responsible for non-preference of some lupine species and varieties to the pea aphid Acyrthosiphon pisum.Download full-size imageHighlights► Total content of alkaloids corresponded with their diversity in a given lupin variety. ► Lupines containing lupanine and its esters were not accepted by pea aphid. ► Deterrent factors took effect during initial stages of probing.