Is suicide an option?: The impact of disability on suicide acceptability in the context of depression, suicidality, and demographic factors

•Participants read five pairs of vignettes about individuals experiencing suicidal ideation.•Each pair contained a disability and no-disability condition.•Suicidality was seen as significantly more acceptable in the disability conditions.•This was true in participants with disabilities or friends or family members with disabilities.•Suicidality, depression, and attitude towards disability predicted greater acceptability.

BackgroundSuicide is a major clinical and public health issue, especially in people with disabilities. However, research on the acceptability of suicide in people with disabilities has not directly compared the relative acceptability of suicidality in people with and without disabilities.MethodAn online sample of five hundred American adults read five pairs of vignettes about individuals who were experiencing suicidal ideation following a life stressor. Each pair contained a disability and no-disability condition; a sixth pair of vignettes discussed suicidal ideation in an elderly individual and contained physical and cognitive disability conditions. Participants completed questions regarding the relative acceptability of suicidality for each vignette as well as demographic items and measures of suicidality, depressive symptoms, and attitude towards disability.ResultsIn all vignette five pairs, suicidality was seen as significantly more acceptable in the disability condition; this was true even when the participants themselves had disabilities or friends or family members with disabilities. Suicidality, depressive symptomology, and more negative attitudes towards disability predicted greater acceptability in both conditions; no factors predicted greater differences between the two conditions.LimitationsThe vignettes in this study focused primarily on individuals in their 20s and most did not compare two disabling conditions.ConclusionsThe greater social acceptability of suicidality in people with disabilities may be taken by individuals with disabilities who are suicidal as implicit permission to end their lives. The potential impact of such social influences should be assessed and addressed by clinicians and suicide prevention advocates.