A new visibility measurement system based on a black target and a comparative trial with visibility instruments

According to Koschmieder's law, a mathematical model of contrast between a single black object and the sky background is established. Based on this principle, we built a black target visiometer system using a photograph of a black object taken with an industrial camera, that has a relatively simple structure and automated operation. In this study, three commercial visibility instruments-a forward scatter meter (CJB-3A) and two atmospheric transmission meters (LT31, VM100)-were compared to the black target visiometer system. Our results show that, within visibility ranges of up to 10 km, 1) all of the instruments agree well at low visibility and agree poorly at a visibility exceeding 5 km; 2) the forward scattering instrument has high bias at low visibility because particle absorption is not included; and 3) the best agreement with the black target method was obtained with the simple transmissometer rather than the forward scatter instrument or the hybrid transmissometer for a visibility range of up to 10 km.