Comparison of different radar technologies and frequencies for road pavement evaluation

Experimental asphalt pavement field measurements have been performed with a commercial Ground Penetrating Radar (GPR) system and with three dedicated, new prototype radars operating at 1-2 GHz, 12-18 GHz and 32 GHz frequency. The aim of these measurements is to find the surface or near-surface permittivity of worn asphalt and to investigate the suitability of various radar technologies for this task. Our experiments were supplemented by drill core samples extracted at selected interesting locations on a test road. As expected, there is hardly any correlation between the results of the four different radars along the same test track, and drill core results complicate the situation further. Taking 10 and 90 percentile cumulative probabilities, the commercial GPR data has the smallest εr′ span from 5 to 5.6, the 1-2 GHz prototype system indicates εr′ between 4.5 and 5.5, our 12-18 GHz system 4.5 to 6.5 and the 32 GHz fixed frequency reflectometer 2.5-4.5. Only the 32 GHz measurements show clearly different mean permittivity values for the visually different pavement surfaces. Test results, however, suggest that extracting air void variation from highly inhomogenous asphalt pavement needs stochastic approach instead of trying to do some deterministic calibrations with pavement cores.