On the accuracy of analytical models of impurity segregation during directional melt crystallization and their applicability for quantitative calculations

The paper deals with the analysis of the accuracy of some one-dimensional (1D) analytical models of the axial distribution of impurities in the crystal grown from a melt. The models proposed by Burton-Prim-Slichter, Ostrogorsky-Muller and Garandet with co-authors are considered, these models are compared to the results of a two-dimensional (2D) numerical simulation. Stationary solutions as well as solutions for the initial transient regime obtained using these models are considered. The sources of errors are analyzed, a conclusion is made about the applicability of 1D analytical models for quantitative estimates of impurity incorporation into the crystal sample as well as for the solution of the inverse problems.