Lifecycle bias in estimates of intergenerational earnings persistence

This paper identifies a significant negative relationship between estimated intergenerational earnings persistence and the age at which fathers are observed. In total, the estimation methodology and the age of the father at observation account for 40 percent of the variation among existing studies. The paper explores two possible causes of this pattern: increasing attenuation bias resulting from growing transitory earnings variance and a lifecycle bias which follows from the rise in permanent earnings variance over the lifecycle. Evidence presented favors the latter explanation over the former. The paper also considers both formal and informal approaches to mitigating the lifecycle bias.