Subjective and objective evaluations of teacher effectiveness: Evidence from New York City

A substantial literature documents large variation in teacher effectiveness at raising student achievement, providing motivation to identify highly effective and ineffective teachers early in their careers. Using data from New York City public schools, we estimate whether subjective evaluations of teacher effectiveness have predictive power for the achievement gains made by teachers' future students. We find that these subjective evaluations have substantial power, comparable with and complementary to objective measures of teacher effectiveness taken from a teacher's first year in the classroom.

Research highlights► We examine data on teachers and students in New York City public schools. ► We estimate subjective evaluations of teacher effectiveness. ► We find subjective evaluations have substantial power to predict student outcomes.