A comparison of regression calibration approaches for designs with internal validation data

We compare the asymptotic relative efficiency of several regression calibration methods of correcting for measurement error in studies with internal validation data, when a single covariate is measured with error. The estimators we consider are appropriate in main study/hybrid validation study designs, where the latter study includes internal validation and may include external validation data. Although all of the methods we consider produce consistent estimates, the method proposed by Spiegelman et al. (Statistics in Medicine, 20 (2001) 139) has an asymptotically smaller variance than the other methods. The methods for measurement error correction are illustrated using a study of the effect of in utero lead exposure on infant birth weight.