Icosahedral and dense random cluster packing in metallic glass structures

It has recently been shown that metallic glass structures can be idealized as inter-penetrating solute-centered atomic clusters that are packed with essentially periodic symmetry. The present work applies the same methodology to explore whether experimental observations can be matched by inter-connected solute-centered clusters that are organized in space via dense random cluster packing, Bergman icosahedral cluster packing or Mackay icosahedral cluster packing. Idealized partial pair distribution functions are developed where the symmetry of the solute positions in the structure is derived from the cluster-packing symmetry and the solute concentration, which establishes occupation of inter-cluster sites, especially β structural sites enclosed by an octahedron of solute-centered clusters. While each of the three models matches major features of the measured solute–solute partial pair distribution functions, the arrangement of clusters with Mackay icosahedral ordering provides the best fit. However, this model is not able to match an essential feature in solute-lean glasses and does not provide the same overall agreement as does periodic cluster packing for solute-rich glasses. Strong similarities between the structure factors in the Mackay icosahedral and periodic cluster-packing models, along with expected deviations from the idealized solute positions studied here, are likely to hinder an unambiguous distinction between these two models.