Outcome after femoral neck fractures: A comparison of Harris Hip Score, Eq-5d and Barthel Index

SummaryIntroductionThe objective of this study was to evaluate the discriminatory ability and responsiveness of the Harris Hips Score, the Barthel Index and the Eq-5d (Euroqol) in an unselected population of patients with displaced femoral neck fracture.MethodsData were collected at 4 and 12 months after surgery from a population of 222 patients. Patients with complete data sets who suffered a serious complication (n = 23) were compared with patients with no complication (n = 56). The assessment scales’ ability to discriminate between the groups was calculated, as was the change score and the standardised response mean.ResultsAll scales were able to discriminate between the complications group and the non-complications group at 4 months, but only Harris Hip Score had independent explanatory ability in a logistic regression analysis. All scales showed a positive change score for the complications group from 4 to 12 months. The standardised response mean was 0.75 for Harris Hip Score, 0.40 for Barthel Index, 0.46 for the Eq-5d index score, and 0.57 for the Eq-5d visual analogue scale. Barthel Index had a marked ceiling effect with 51/79 (65%) scoring 19 or 20 at 4 months. The response rate was 71–87% for Eq-5d and 96–98% for Harris Hip Score and Barthel Index.ConclusionAll the scales may be used for this patient group, but Harris Hip Score performed better than the other scales.