A curious case of superscript (−1): Prospective secondary mathematics teachers explain

•We extend a discussion on how knowledge of advanced mathematics (or lack of it) can guide instructional interaction.•We investigate how prospective teachers explain the use of the symbol superscript (−1) for inverse of a function and a reciprocal of a fraction.•We demonstrate the applicability of scripting tasks for exploring mathematical knowledge and pedagogical choices.

In mathematics the same symbol – superscript (−1) – is used to indicate an inverse of a function and a reciprocal of a rational number. Is there a reason for using the same symbol in both cases? We analyze the responses of prospective secondary school teachers to this question. The responses are presented in a form of a dialogue between a teacher and a student and are accompanied with participants’ commentary on their choices of instructional approaches. The data show that the majority of participants treat the symbol ☐−1 as a homonym, that is, the symbol is assigned different and unrelated meanings depending on a context. We discuss how knowledge of advanced mathematics (or lack of it) can guide instructional interaction.