Irredundant intersections of valuation overrings of two-dimensional Noetherian domains

Let D be a two-dimensional Noetherian domain, let R be an overring of D, and let Σ and Γ be collections of valuation overrings of D. We consider circumstances under which (⋂V∈ΣV)∩R=(⋂W∈ΓW)∩R implies that Σ=Γ. We show that if R is integrally closed, these representations are “strongly” irredundant, and every member of Σ∪Γ has Krull dimension 2, then Σ=Γ. If in addition Σ and Γ are Noetherian subspaces of the Zariski–Riemann space of the quotient field of D (e.g. if Σ and Γ have finite character), then the restriction that the members of Σ∪Γ have Krull dimension 2 can be omitted. An example shows that these results do not extend to overrings of three-dimensional Noetherian domains.