Comments on “Drill-string horizontal dynamics with uncertainty on the frictional force” by T.G. Ritto, M.R. Escalante, Rubens Sampaio, M.B. Rosales [J. Sound Vib. 332 (2013) 145-153]

This paper analyzes the mechanical and mathematical models in “Ritto et al. (2013) [1]”. The results are that: (1) the mechanical model is obviously incorrect; (2) the mathematical model is not complete; (3) the differential equation is obviously incorrect; (4) the finite element equation is obviously not discretized from the corresponding mathematical model above, and is obviously incorrect. A mathematical model of dynamics should include the differential equations, the boundary conditions and the initial conditions.