Analyzing evolutionary optimization and community detection algorithms using regression line dominance

In this paper, a visual analysis methodology is proposed to perform comparative analysis of guided random algorithms such as evolutionary optimization algorithms and community detection algorithms. Proposed methodology is designed based on quantile-quantile plot and regression analysis to compare performance of one algorithm over other algorithms. The methodology is extrapolated as one-to-one comparison, one-to-many comparison and many-to-many comparison of solution quality and convergence rate. Most of the existing approaches utilize both solution quality and convergence rate to perform comparative analysis. However, the many-to-many comparison i.e. ranking of algorithms is done only with solution quality. On the contrary, with proposed methodology ranking of algorithms is done in terms of both solution quality and convergence rate. Proposed methodology is studied with four evolutionary optimization algorithms on 25 benchmark functions. A non-parametric statistical analysis called Wilcoxon signed-rank test is also performed to verify the indication of proposed methodology. Moreover, methodology is also applied to analyze four state-of-the-art community detection algorithms on 10 real-world networks.