Comparison of linear and square superposition hardening models for the surface nanoindentation of ion-irradiated materials

Linear and square superposition hardening models are compared for the surface nanoindentation of ion-irradiated materials. Hardening mechanisms of both dislocations and defects within the plasticity affected region (PAR) are considered. Four sets of experimental data for ion-irradiated materials are adopted to compare with theoretical results of the two hardening models. It is indicated that both models describe experimental data equally well when the PAR is within the irradiated layer; whereas, when the PAR is beyond the irradiated region, the square superposition hardening model performs better. Therefore, the square superposition model is recommended to characterize the hardening behavior of ion-irradiated materials.