An Analysis of Assortment Choice in Grocery Retailing

•Perception of variety impacts consumer decisions process in selecting assortments.•Theory suggests that consumers demand less variety for high-quality product assortments and vice versa.•Assortment choice is analyzed using a model that allows for substitution and complementarity, and takes into account demand interactions among items.•Empirical evidence is found for the mediating role of product quality in consumer demand for assortment variety.

Consumers in grocery retailing commonly buy bundles of products to accommodate current and future consumption. When all products in a particular bundle share common attributes (and are selected from the same product category), the consumer is said to assemble an assortment. This research examines the impact of assortment variety on the assortment choice process. In particular, we test the prediction that consumers demand less variety for higher quality items. To investigate this relationship, we employ a flexible choice model, suitable for the analysis of assortment choice. The model, based upon the assumption that the utility of purchase of one item in an assortment depends upon the set of items already selected, allows for a general utility structure across the assortment items. We apply the model to household assortment choice histories from the yogurt product category. Substantively, we show that yogurt choice is affected by brand quality perceptions (quality-tier competition). Moreover, we show that reaction to reductions in variety (number of yogurt flavors) is mediated by brand quality perceptions. Taken together, these empirical facts paint a picture of a consumer who is willing to trade-off variety against product quality in assortment choice.

Graphical abstractFigure optionsDownload full-size imageDownload as PowerPoint slide