Local perceptions of the relative contributions of enclave tourism and agritourism to community well-being: The case of Mauritius

•Compares the perceptions of the local community of the extent to which enclave tourism and agritourism contribute to their wellbeing.•Both types of tourism development contribute both positively and negatively to community wellbeing although enclave tourism is perceived to have fewer positive outcomes.•Enclave tourism provides valuable educational and cultural opportunities but damages the environment, restricts entrepreneurship and favours local elites.•Agritourism, positively enhance the cultural and social spheres of community life whilst supporting entrepreneurship.

To date, limited attention has been paid to the contribution of tourism to the well-being of island residents in general and to whether such well-being varies according to the nature of tourism development in particular. Specifically, island tourism is frequently manifested in resort-based enclave development, a form of tourism that is often criticised for its assumed limited benefits to the wider community. As a consequence, alternative approaches such as agritourism, are increasingly proposed as a means of enhancing community development and well-being, yet the relative merits of enclave and agritourism have not been explored within an island tourism context. This paper addresses this notable gap in the literature. Drawing on a questionnaire-based survey in Mauritius, it considers and compares the perceptions of local people of the extent to which enclave tourism and agritourism contribute to their well-being. The results reveal that both types of tourism development contribute both positively and negatively to community well-being although enclave tourism is perceived to have fewer positive outcomes. On the one hand, enclave tourism provides valuable cultural opportunities but damages the environment, restricts entrepreneurship and favours local elites; on the other hand, agritourism, although not yet well-established in Mauritius, is perceived to positively enhance the cultural and social spheres of community life whilst supporting entrepreneurship.