Article ID Journal Published Year Pages File Type
331629 New Ideas in Psychology 2016 9 Pages PDF
Abstract

In this paper, I juxtapose the Symbol Grounding Problem and causal theories of reference. In the first part of the paper, I show some basic assumptions they share in order to show, in the second part, some difficulties implied by these assumptions. These difficulties are: the meaning determination problem, the easy and hard disjunction problem, and the trivialization problem. My diagnosis is that both the easy and hard disjunction problem result from a more general difficulty with causal theories and the SGP solution, which is the possibility of misrepresenting, and in particular of accounting for system-detectable error. I emphasize some implications they have for the notion of representation. Finally, I enumerate some theoretical desiderata for a satisfactory account of naturalized semantics (and solutions to SGP) that would be free of the problems mentioned above.

Related Topics
Social Sciences and Humanities Psychology Developmental and Educational Psychology
Authors
,