The efficiency of a closed-loop chemical-free water treatment system for cyprinid fish farms

The study presented has been carried out to evaluate the treatment performance, fish production and water consumption of a closed-loop chemical-free water treatment system for small-scale cyprinid fish farms. The closed-loop system consisted of a 36 m3 experimental pond (Pond A) with initial carp load of 1 kg/m3 (34 Cyprinus c. carpio); of a treatment train (TT) with a roughing filter (RF), glass fibre filters (GFF), and UV-C units (UV); and of an ultrasound unit (US) installed in the corner of the pond. The average circulation of the water in the closed-loop system was 2.3 times per day. Pond A was compared with a control pond (Pond B) of the same dimensions and fish load but with no TT or US. The TT was efficient in the removal of total suspended solids, biochemical oxygen demand, chemical oxygen demand, total coliforms (TC), and faecal coliforms (FC), reaching 35%, 42%, 33%, 37%, 91% and 91% removal, respectively. The majority of pollutant removal took place in the RF, while the GFF contributed mostly to the removal of TC and FC. UV did not contribute to the removal of bacteria, mostly due to low TC and FC inputs. The removal of nutrients in the TT (ammonia, nitrites, nitrates, total phosphorous and orto-phosphate) was not efficient. Despite this, Pond A had markedly lower nutrient concentrations compared to Pond B, and all the mean values of the measured parameters except nitrites and total phosphorous in Pond A were below legislation limit. Specific growth rate and fish body weight increase in Pond A were higher than in Pond B (0.3%/day, 0.2%/day, 152% and 115%, respectively) indicating better rearing conditions in Pond A. However, fish showed with 2.8 in Pond A and 3.3 in Pond B poor feed conversion rate over warm months. Higher water consumption in Pond A was due to various interventions during the pilot operation that can be reduced in normal operation. The results showed that the closed-loop system presented could be useful for semi-natural fish farming of 1–2 kg fish/m3. However, the system should be improved with regular sedimented algae removal to avoid nutrient accumulation.