Space competition between seagrass and Caulerpa prolifera (Forsskaal) Lamouroux following simulated disturbances in Lassing Park, FL

An experimental study was conducted in Tampa Bay, FL to examine the response to disturbance of two co-occurring subtidal plants: the alga Caulerpa prolifera and the seagrass Halodule wrightii (Ascherson). Some recent studies have called into question the assumption that fast-growing rhizoidal Caulerpa species have the potential to outcompete and rapidly replace local seagrasses. In the Fall of 2002 an abrupt appearance of Caulerpa prolifera was noted in a shallow embayment in Tampa Bay previously dominated by seagrasses. Natural disturbance events were simulated by excavating 0.5 × 0.5 m plots in an area with monospecific C. prolifera and mixed C. prolifera and H. wrightii. Above and below-ground biomass were removed, and recovery of above-ground cover into the newly created gaps was monitored over 15 months. In addition to measuring the recovery of both species, the spatial pattern of Caulerpa recovery from the simulated disturbances was also analyzed. Simulated gaps were rapidly (5–8 months, depending on sampling resolution) and exclusively reoccupied by C. prolifera, with the recovery occurring predominantly via lateral expansion from gap edges rather than colonization by fragments. Therefore, while rhizoidal algae may or may not be able to supplant existing seagrasses by overgrowth or other forms of direct competition, disturbance events that remove seagrass and create bare areas may allow C. prolifera to replace seagrasses over time via preemption of space should an algal bloom such as this be persistent.