From large to small: Reorienting rural development policies in response to climate change, food security and poverty

• We critically reflect on policies for the development of the Amazon.
• Policies are still oriented to capitalised actors and provoke undesired consequences.
• Policies ignore smallholders' capacities to contribute to a sound local development.
• Policies should promote small-scale production systems instead of replacing them.
• Smallholders are part of the solution rather than an obstacle to rural development.

Discourses regarding the development of the Amazon region highlight the importance of the local cultures, local knowledge and participation of smallholders, such as indigenous people, traditional communities and small-scale colonists. Current policies, however, still pursue a development model that is oriented towards global commodity markets and the capacity of well-qualified entrepreneurs with the capital required for large-scale investments, despite a growing consensus on its ecological incompatibilities, social limitations and economic risks. Decision makers from both governmental and non-governmental organisations widely disregard the possibility that smallholders could more actively contribute to rural development. Instead, the production practices of smallholders and their modes of social organisation are perceived as obsolete and inefficient. By presenting examples from the region, this paper argues that smallholders have the potential to manage production systems that maintain environmental stability while effectively contributing to local well-being. Therefore, the paper advocates to more effectively using local capacities for the development of rural Amazon through the promotion of small-scale production systems.