Optimization and comparative evaluation of nonlinear deformation algorithms for atlas-based segmentation of DBS target nuclei

Here, we systematically evaluated the performance of six modern and established algorithms on subcortical normalization and segmentation results by calculating over 11,000 nonlinear warps in over 100 subjects. For each algorithm, we evaluated its performance using T1-or T2-weighted acquisitions alone or a combination of T1-, T2-and PD-weighted acquisitions in parallel. Furthermore, we present optimized parameters for the best performing algorithms. We tested each algorithm on two datasets, a state-of-the-art MRI cohort of young subjects and a cohort of subjects age- and MR-quality-matched to a typical DBS Parkinson's Disease cohort. Our final pipeline is able to segment DBS targets with precision comparable to manual expert segmentations in both cohorts. Although the present study focuses on the two prominent DBS targets, STN and GPi, these methods may extend to other small subcortical structures like thalamic nuclei or the nucleus accumbens.