Comparison of Wicke–Kallenbach and Graham's diffusion cells for obtaining transport characteristics of porous solids

Counter-current gas diffusion measurements on a series of porous solids covering a broad range of pore sizes (mean pore radii between 78 nm and 10μm) were performed in the Wicke–Kallenbach and Graham's diffusion cells. Mutual agreement of diffusion fluxes from both cells was found in the whole range of tested pore radii and inert gas systems. For pore materials with mean pore radii exceeding 5μm the experimentally unavoidable tiny total pressure gradient induces additional permeation flow which precludes the use of Graham's law for evaluation of transport parameters of the porous solids. Transport parameters together with 95% confidence regions were determined for porous materials with pore radii up to 5μm and the prevailing diffusion mechanism, intimately connected with the shape of confidence regions, was estimated.