Evaluation of the SPOT/VEGETATION Collection 3 reprocessed dataset: Surface reflectances and NDVI

After the end of the 'Satellite Pour l'Observation de la Terre' (SPOT) VEGETATION (SPOT/VGT) mission in May/2014, the SPOT/VGT data archive, consisting of raw data coming from both the VEGETATION 1 (VGT1) and VEGETATION 2 (VGT2) instruments, was reprocessed, aiming at improved cloud screening and correcting for known artefacts such as the smile pattern in the VGT2 Blue band and the Sun-Earth distance bug in Top-of-Atmosphere reflectance calculation, with the objective of improving temporal consistency. The aim of this paper is to inform the user community of the changes in and the evaluation of the new SPOT/VGT Collection 3 (VGT-C3). The evaluation of the reprocessing is based on (i) the relative comparison between SPOT/VGT Collection 2 (VGT-C2) and VGT-C3 surface reflectances and Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI), (ii) consistency analysis between VGT1-C3 and VGT2-C3, and (iii) the comparison of the archive with external datasets from METOP/Advanced Very High Resolution Radiometer (AVHRR) and TERRA/Moderate Resolution Imaging Spectroradiometer (MODIS). Surface reflectances are slightly higher after the reprocessing, with larger differences in July compared to January, caused by the corrected Sun-Earth distance modelling. For NDVI, the overall impact of the reprocessing is relatively small and differences show no seasonality. Trends in the differences over the years are related to changes in calibration coefficients. Systematic differences between VGT1-C3 and VGT2-C3 surface reflectance are well below 1%, with largest bias between VGT1 and VGT2 for the NIR band and the NDVI (VGT2 > VGT1, especially for larger NDVI values). Both the comparison with METOP/AVHRR (surface reflectance and NDVI) and TERRA/MODIS (NDVI) reveal trends over time: systematic bias between VGT2 and METOP/AVHRR tends to decrease over time, while comparison with TERRA/MODIS indicates an increasing bias between VGT2 and MODIS. VGT2 NDVI seems to be gradually evolving to slightly larger values, which is consistent with the change in overpass time of VGT2 and the different illumination conditions caused by the orbital drift of the sensor. Results demonstrate however the SPOT/VGT-C3 archive is more stable over time compared to the previous archive, although bidirectional reflectance distribution function (BRDF) normalization is recommended in order to correct for bidirectional effects.