The effect of water on recrystallization behavior and grain boundary morphology in calcite-observations of natural marble mylonites

Fluids are inferred to play a major role in the deformation and recrystallization of many minerals (e.g. quartz, olivine, halite, feldspar). In this study, we sought to identify the effect of fluids on grain boundary morphology and recrystallization processes in marble mylonites during shear zone evolution. We compared the chemistry, microstructure and mesostructure of calcite marble mylonites from the Schneeberg Complex, Southern Tyrole, Italy, to that from the Naxos Metamorphic Core Complex, Greece. These two areas were selected for comparison because they have similar lithology and resemble each other in chemical composition. In addition, calcite-dolomite geothermometry indicates similar temperatures for shear zone formation: 279±25 °C (Schneeberg Complex) and 271±15 °C (Naxos high-grade core). However, the two settings are different in the nature of the fluids present during the shear zone evolution. In the Schneeberg mylonites, both the alteration of minerals during retrograde metamorphism in the neighboring micaschists and the existence of veins suggest that aqueous fluids were present during mylonitization. The absence of these features in the Naxos samples indicates that aqueous fluids were not as prevalent during deformation. This conclusion is also supported by the stable isotope signature. Observations of broken and planar surfaces using optical and scanning electron microscopes did not indicate major differences between the two mylonites: grain boundaries in both settings display pores with shapes controlled by crystallography, and have pore morphologies that are similar to observations from crack and grain-boundary healing experiments. Grain size reduction was predominantly the result of subgrain rotation recrystallization. However, the coarse grains inside the wet protomylonites (Schneeberg) are characterized by intracrystalline shear zones.