Professionalism in political broadcast talk: The performance of a distancing journalistic self in formatted pre-election debates

This article focuses on journalistic self-presentations within political television talk. While previous studies have explored quite extensively how journalists manage to achieve a “neutralistic” posture within news interviews and other forms of political broadcast talk, they have been cautious about incorporating reflections on the role of programme formats. This study raises questions about how televisual formats (can) play a role in the formulation of a professional, distancing journalistic self in political television programmes. The analysis draws on transcriptions of 19 pre-election debates broadcast on Flemish public service television (VRT) in 2009. Inspired by a conversation analytic framework and building on [4], [6], [8] and [9] findings on the use of footing shifts in news interviews, the analysis shows that the presence of pre-produced, format-related components, such as public surveys, reportages and expert commentaries, enlarges the journalist-presenters' “pool” of strategic resources to reach, defend and legitimise a neutralistic stance.

► Political broadcast talk involves dynamic on-air journalistic self-presentations.
► Programme formats can be related to journalists performances of a distancing self.
► Journalists can use format components as resources to reach a defensible stance.
► Supporting and controlling potential of televisual production processes.