On the role of symmetries in the theory of photonic crystals

We discuss the role of the symmetries in photonic crystals and classify them according to the Cartan–Altland–Zirnbauer scheme. Of particular importance are complex conjugation CC and time-reversal TT, but we identify also other significant symmetries. Borrowing the jargon of the classification theory of topological insulators, we show that CC is a “particle–hole-type symmetry” rather than a “time-reversal symmetry” if one considers the Maxwell operator in the first-order formalism where the dynamical Maxwell equations can be rewritten as a Schrödinger equation; The symmetry which implements physical time-reversal is a “chiral-type symmetry”. We justify by an analysis of the band structure why the first-order formalism seems to be more advantageous than the second-order formalism. Moreover, based on the Schrödinger formalism, we introduce a class of effective (tight-binding) models called Maxwell–Harper operators. Some considerations about the breaking of the “particle–hole-type symmetry” in the case of gyrotropic crystals are added at the end of this paper.