Evidence for a breed specific association between PrP genotype and ultrasonic muscle depth but not for survivability, growth or carcass traits in sheep

The ARR allele of the prion protein gene is associated with resistance to classical scrapie, while the ARQ allele is associated with susceptibility. The objective of this study was to estimate the effect, on lamb growth and carcass traits, of replacing an ARQ allele with an ARR allele. Pedigree rams (22 Suffolks, 18 Texels and 18 Charollais) were sourced in pairs, from the same flock (by the same sire where possible), with one member being ARR/ARR and the other being ARQ/ARQ and these rams were progeny tested through single-sire mating in six flocks. Effects of ram genotype on reproductive performance of ewes and on growth and carcass traits of progeny were estimated using mixed model procedures with sire as a random effect. Ram genotype had no effect on litter size at birth or on lamb survival as measured by the number of lambs reared. The differences between the performance of progeny by ARR/ARR and ARQ/ARQ sires provided an estimate of the effect of substituting an ARR allele for an ARQ allele. This allele substitution had no effect on birth weight, growth rate, weight at 5 or 14 weeks, weight or ultrasonic fat depth at 120 days of age or on carcass classification traits (conformation, fatness) for the Suffolk, Texel or Charollais breeds. Substituting an ARR allele for an ARQ allele had a negative effect on ultrasonic muscle depth at 120 days for the progeny of Suffolk rams (P = 0.01) but had a positive effect on ultrasonic muscle depth at 120 days for the progeny of Charollais rams (P = 0.02). The ARR substitution effect was negative for slaughter age in the Suffolk (P < 0.05) and positive for carcass weight in Texel progeny (P < 0.05). The magnitude of these effects was quite small, however, and the overall results support the hypothesis that substituting an ARR allele for an ARQ allele has no important negative effect on lamb growth or carcass traits in any of the breeds examined.