A general lock-free algorithm using compare-and-swap

The compare-and-swap register (CAS) is a synchronization primitive for lock-free algorithms. Most uses of it, however, suffer from the so-called ABA problem. The simplest and most efficient solution to the ABA problem is to include a tag with the memory location such that the tag is incremented with each update of the target location. This solution, however, is theoretically unsound and has limited applicability. This paper presents a general lock-free pattern that is based on the synchronization primitive CAS without causing ABA problem or problems with wrap around. It can be used to provide lock-free functionality for any data type. Our algorithm is a CAS variation of Herlihy’s LL/SC methodology for lock-free transformation. The basis of our techniques is to poll different locations on reading and writing objects in such a way that the consistency of an object can be checked by its location instead of its tag. It consists of simple code that can be easily implemented using C-like languages. A true problem of lock-free algorithms is that they are hard to design correctly, which even holds for apparently straightforward algorithms. We therefore develop a reduction theorem that enables us to reason about the general lock-free algorithm to be designed on a higher level than the synchronization primitives. The reduction theorem is based on Lamport’s refinement mappings, and has been verified with the higher-order interactive theorem prover PVS. Using the reduction theorem, fewer invariants are required and some invariants are easier to discover and formulate without considering the internal structure of the final implementation.