Variable impacts of enchytraeid worms and ectomycorrhizal fungi on plant growth in raw humus soil treated with wood ash

An increasing amount of evidence shows the context dependent nature of various biotic interactions across terrestrial and aquatic ecosystems. We established a laboratory experiment to study whether the effects of Cognettia sphagnetorum (Enchytraeidae) and ectomycorrhizal fungi on Scots pine (Pinus sylvestris) seedling growth are influenced by wood ash application. Acidic coniferous forest soil was treated with wood ash at 5000 kg ha−1 or left as ash-free control and inoculated with soil saprotrophic microbes and nematodes. The microcosms were destructively sampled 26 and 51 weeks after initiation of the experiment. We measured enchytraeid and pine seedling biomass, abundance of nematodes and leaching of NH4+-N and NO3−-N at both samplings, and root length and N concentration of pine needles at the end of the experiment. On average enchytraeids and mycorrhizal fungi enhanced pine biomass production in the ash-free control soils, however, their impact was most pronounced when these organisms were alone in the systems. In fact, mycorrhizas tended to have a negative impact on the seedlings in the presence of enchytraeids. Wood ash had a clear negative impact on enchytraeid populations. Wood ash decreased pine growth when enchytraeids and EM-fungi were alone in the systems, but when together they apparently compensated for the negative effects of wood ash on the seedlings. It is concluded that interactions between soil fauna, mycorrhizal fungi and plants are context dependent, thereby rendering predictions of the outcome of species interactions in soil food webs a demanding task.