The effect of Stratiotes aloides L. and nutrients on the growth rate of Lemna minor L.

We tried to find the reasons for frequently observed low biomass of Lemna minor among floating rosettes of Stratiotes aloides as opposed to the abundance of Spirodela polyrhiza in these stands. The effect of S. aloides on L. minor was analysed in outdoor culture experiments. The duckweed collected from among dense stands of the floating form of S. aloides (test sites) showed a significantly lower growth rate than that from stands free of the water soldier (control sites). Water from the latter stands was significantly richer in nitrate-nitrogen and ammonium-nitrogen, but not in soluble reactive phosphorus suggesting possible nutrient depletion as a reason for observed differences. Growth rates of L. minor were indeed significantly correlated with in situ concentrations of all dissolved nutrients and showed saturation at around 0.18 mg N-NH4 dm−3 and 0.05 mg SRP dm−3 above which the growth rates did not increase significantly. We used stepwise regression to test the combined effect of nutrients and the presence/absence of S. aloides on the growth rate of L. minor. The regression showed a negligible effect of ammonium ions and nitrates on the growth rate of the duckweed. At low concentrations of soluble reactive phosphorus the presence of both the S. aloides and SRP concentrations significantly affected the growth of L. minor. Above saturating SRP concentrations none of the two effects was significant. Results of our experiments seem to suggest that the presence of S. aloides exerts a negative effect on the growth of L. minor only at low concentrations of soluble phosphorus. Since the depletion of nutrients in water by the floating form of S. aloides is unlikely, we point to S. polyrhiza as a superior competitor for nutrients and suggest a possible allelopathic effect of the water soldier on L. minor.