Evaluation of plankton surface pushnets and oblique tows for comparing the catch of diadromous larval fish

A bow-mounted surface pushnet and an obliquely towed plankton net were compared to evaluate gear efficiency and effectiveness in collecting larval fishes under daytime and nighttime conditions. The diadromous species targeted were striped bass Morone saxatilis, white perch, Morone americana, and river herring Alosa sp. We sampled the lower Roanoke River, North Carolina, from March through June of 2002 and 2003. Striped bass, white perch and river herring represented over 90% of the larvae collected during the study period. Mean larval densities (number/100 m3) were 63.4 for striped bass, 26.4 for river herring, and 17.7 for white perch. Striped bass larval densities were significantly higher in the surface pushnet for both years (P ≤ 0.05). In 2002, white perch mean larval density was significantly higher at night in the surface pushnet samples, but in 2003 there were no differences between day and night samples. River herring mean densities were significantly higher in the surface pushnets for both years, but showed no clear patterns between day and night samples. Larger larvae were consistently collected in the surface pushnets for all species. Overall, the surface pushnet was easier to operate. The pushnet was mounted on the bow of a small jon boat and required less specialized gear and fewer personnel than oblique sampling. The method also allows for sampling in shallow water or vegetated habitats. Because larvae were significantly larger in the surface samples, using surface pushnets may not allow for detection of the smaller-sized larvae therefore underestimating the abundance of smaller fish. Depending on the question being asked, we recommend that sampling programs should use both gear types to reduce any gear biases.