Grazing activity of Pfiesteria piscicida (Dinophyceae) and susceptibility to ciliate predation vary with toxicity status

Variability has been reported in the toxicity potential of Pfiesteria piscicida that is partly a function of the history of exposure to live fish. Grazing properties of P. piscicida and its susceptibility to ciliate predation were compared in three functional types or toxicity states of this species: actively toxic cultures, cultures with temporary loss of demonstrable toxicity, and cultures with no demonstrable toxicity. Pronounced differences in predator-prey interactions were found between actively toxic cultures and cultures with reduced toxicity. When grown with Rhodomonas sp. (Cryptophyceae) prey, specific growth rates were relatively low in actively toxic cultures under both relatively high and low irradiances. In the cultures with reduced toxicity, prey chloroplast material was apparent in nearly 100% of dinoflagellate cells 3 h after feeding, while chloroplast inclusions were found in <40% of actively toxic cells for ≤16 h (high light) and ≤23 h (low light). These results suggest a relatively high reliance on phagotrophic carbon assimilation and more rapid response to algal prey availability in Pfiesteria cells with lower toxicity. Grazing by two euplotid benthic ciliates (Euplotes vannus and E. woodruffi) on P. piscicida also varied among functional types. Grazing on actively toxic P. piscicida cells did not occur, whereas net positive ingestion rates were calculated for the other prey cultures. These results support concurrent experimental findings that a natural assemblage of microzooplankton displayed lower grazing potential on actively toxic P. piscicida than on cultures with reduced toxicity. In summary, pronounced differences in trophic interactions were found between actively toxic cultures and those with reduced or undetectable toxicity, providing additional evidence of the importance of cellular toxicity in the trophic ecology of Pfiesteria.