Effect of aboveground and belowground interactions on the intercrop yields in maize-soybean relay intercropping systems

The photosynthetically active radiation (PAR) transmittances of maize wide-row were significantly higher than those of maize narrow-row at the sixth leaf stage (jointing stage), twelfth leaf stage (bell stage), and tasseling stage. Specifically, PAR transmittances decreased as maize narrow-row spacing increased. No significant differences in the PAR transmittances of maize narrow-row or wide-row were found between the R1 and R2 conditions. Similarly, no significant differences between intercrop biomass and grain yield were observed between the R1 and R2 conditions. By contrast, different row configuration treatments exhibited significant differences in biomass (whole growth period for soybean and after tasseling stage for maize), grain yield and photosynthetic parameters of intercrops. These results implied that aboveground interactions, such as mutual shading, have more significant contributions to intercrop advantages than belowground interactions. In addition, the intercropped maize yields increased as maize narrow-row spacing (from P1 to P3 treatment) increased. However, contrasting trends were found for intercropped soybean yield and land equivalent ration (LER). No significant differences in LER were observed between R1 and R2 conditions in different row configurations. P1 treatment exhibited the maximum LER (1.64 for 2013 and 1.83 for 2014) and mixed yield (7430 kg ha−1 for 2013 and 9559 kg ha−1 for 2014), but the lower maize yield compared with P2 and P3 treatments. This result suggested that reducing the competitive ability of maize while increasing that of soybean significantly improves intercropping advantage in maize-soybean relay intercropping systems.