Identifying oilseed rape varieties with high yield and low nitrogen fertiliser requirement

Reducing the fertiliser nitrogen (N) requirement of oilseed rape (Brassica napus L.) whilst maintaining yield will be beneficial for both growers and the environment. The aim of this paper was to identify differences in fertiliser N requirement between varieties and investigate simple in-field methods to rapidly identify varieties that can maintain high yield whilst requiring lower optimal N rates ('HYLO' varieties) to aid breeding for lower N fertiliser requirement. Four field experiments were conducted in the UK during seasons 2011-12 or 2012-13 on a range of soil types. Each experiment included 21 elite open pollinated and hybrid varieties. Each variety was grown at seven levels of N fertiliser ranging from zero to super-optimal (340 or 400 kg N/ha). Measurements of seed yield and seed oil content were combined to calculate gross output yield, i.e. seed yield adjusted for oil content. Linear plus exponential yield response curves were fitted to calculate the economically optimum N rate (Nopt) of each variety and the associated nitrogen use efficiency (NUE) was calculated at the Nopt. Across varieties, gross output yield responses to optimum N fertiliser, compared with yields at nil N rates, were significant, ranging from 1.3 to 2.7 t/ha between sites. Nopt ranged from 117 to 286 kg N/ha between sites giving experimental average yields at Nopt (Yopt) of 3.0 to 4.6 t/ha. Varietal yield ranges at Nopt within each experiment ranged from 0.6 to 1.7 t/ha, and there was a positive trend for yield to increase with date of variety introduction by 0.24 t/ha per decade. Significant variety x N fertiliser rate interactions were measured for gross output yield in two out of four experiments and significant varietal differences in Nopt were measured in one experiment ranging from 195 kg N/ha to 296 kg N/ha. There was no correlation between Nopt and Yopt indicating that improving varietal yield potential will not necessarily increase N requirement. Significant varietal differences in NUE were measured at Nopt ranging from 13.5 to 15.9 kg of gross output yield per kg of N supply from soil residues and fertiliser. Seed with low N and high oil content, and high biomass harvest index could be useful indicators of high NUE. However, no single trait correlated consistently with varietal variation in NUE. The yield difference between sub- and super-optimal N rates was positively correlated with Nopt. Further research is required to develop new experimental approaches for measuring yield at more than one N level on small experimental plot areas and to investigate a wider range of genotypes.