کد مقاله کد نشریه سال انتشار مقاله انگلیسی نسخه تمام متن
935759 923918 2012 17 صفحه PDF دانلود رایگان
عنوان انگلیسی مقاله ISI
Protolanguage and the “God particle”
موضوعات مرتبط
علوم انسانی و اجتماعی علوم انسانی و هنر زبان و زبان شناسی
پیش نمایش صفحه اول مقاله
Protolanguage and the “God particle”
چکیده انگلیسی

Most scholars investigating the evolution of language subscribe to the hypothesis that protolanguage occurred as an intermediate stage between the speechless state of our remote ancestors and modern language. But some scholars – Noam Chomsky and fellow biolinguists, Bernd Heine and Tania Kuteva, and others – have expressed serious doubts about the existence of protolanguage. The present article investigates the cause of this disagreement and what it reveals about the nature of influential modern work on language evolution. It does this by analysing the case made by Derek Bickerton for the existence of protolanguage, as well as Noam Chomsky's case against the existence of protolanguage. Both cases are shown to be weak, resting on a range of implicit and/or contentious assumptions. Invoking a conceptual distinction illustrated by physicists’ hunt for the “God particle”, the article argues that the case for the existence of protolanguage has not been strengthened by recent work attributing specific properties to protolanguage. To conclude, the article discusses the conceptual means needed for shoring up the assumption that evidence for the existence of protolanguage can be derived from so-called living linguistic fossils.


► I analyse Derek Bickerton's case for the existence of protolanguage: it is weak.
► I analyse Noam Chomsky's case against the existence of protolanguage: it is weak.
► Both cases rest on unsupported or controversial assumptions.
► “Living linguistic fossils” do not provide pertinent evidence for protolanguage.
► Bridge theories are needed for strengthening the case for protolanguage.

ناشر
Database: Elsevier - ScienceDirect (ساینس دایرکت)
Journal: Lingua - Volume 122, Issue 12, September 2012, Pages 1308–1324
نویسندگان
,