DNA Fragmentation as an Early Indicator of Extender Efficacy: A Preliminary Study

Evaluation of new potential semen extenders is a field of economic and scientific importance, but assessing motility alone may not be sufficient. The objectives of this study were to examine the effect of oxidative damage by short-term exposure to H2O2 on stallion sperm motility and DNA fragmentation and to correlate motility to the percentage of DNA damage as assessed by both terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase-mediated dUTP nick end labeling (TUNEL) and single-cell gel electrophoresis assays. Motility and DNA fragmentation were determined immediately before cooling (0 hour) and at 24 hours postcooling. The addition of H2O2 (300 μM) to the extender had no effect on either total or progressive motility (P > .05). DNA fragmentation as determined by both Comet and TUNEL assays did not differ between 0 hour and those cells stored for 24 hours in the absence of H2O2 (P > .05). However, the addition of H2O2 to the extender plus incubation for 24 hours resulted in greater total Comet length, tail length, and tail moment as well as an increase in percentage of sperm cells with DNA damage detected by TUNEL compared to 0 hour (P < .05). Motility was not correlated with DNA damaged cells detected by TUNEL or Comet assays (P > .05). In conclusion, although both the Comet assay and TUNEL detected significant DNA fragmentation in cells exposed to H2O2, there was not a significant or appreciable effect of H2O2 on motility. Therefore, motility alone is likely not the best laboratory assay with which to assess cooled extender efficacy.