کد مقاله کد نشریه سال انتشار مقاله انگلیسی نسخه تمام متن
1160654 1490338 2013 8 صفحه PDF دانلود رایگان
عنوان انگلیسی مقاله ISI
Normativity, the base-rate fallacy, and some problems for retail realism
موضوعات مرتبط
علوم انسانی و اجتماعی علوم انسانی و هنر تاریخ
پیش نمایش صفحه اول مقاله
Normativity, the base-rate fallacy, and some problems for retail realism
چکیده انگلیسی


• Discusses recent literature concerned with the base-rate fallacy.
• Argues that responses to this worry undermine the traditional scientific realism debate.
• Locates the problem in a poorly articulated naturalistic methodology.

Recent literature in the scientific realism debate has been concerned with a particular species of statistical fallacy concerning base-rates, and the worry that no matter how predictively successful our contemporary scientific theories may be, this will tell us absolutely nothing about the likelihood of their truth if our overall sample space contains enough empirically adequate theories that are nevertheless false. In response, both realists and anti-realists have switched their focus from general arguments concerning the reliability and historical track-records of our scientific methodology, to a series of specific arguments and case-studies concerning our reasons to believe individual scientific theories to be true. Such a development however sits in tension with the usual understanding of the scientific realism debate as offering a second-order assessment of our first-order scientific practices, and threatens to undermine the possibility of a distinctive philosophical debate over the approximate truth of our scientific theories. I illustrate this concern with three recent attempts to offer a more localised understanding of the scientific realism debate—due to Stathis Psillos, Juha Saatsi, and Kyle Stanford—and argue that none of these alternatives offer a satisfactory response to the problem.

ناشر
Database: Elsevier - ScienceDirect (ساینس دایرکت)
Journal: Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part A - Volume 44, Issue 4, December 2013, Pages 563–570
نویسندگان
,