Dealing with Requests for Euthanasia: Interview Study Among General Practitioners in Belgium

ContextIn many countries, physicians are confronted with requests for euthanasia. Notwithstanding that euthanasia is legally permitted in Belgium, it remains the subject of intense debate.ObjectivesTo gather in-depth empirical data on how general practitioners (GPs) deal with these requests in Belgium.MethodsMortality follow-back study in 2005–2006 via the nationwide Sentinel Network of General Practitioners. Standardized face-to-face interviews were conducted with GPs for all the reported patients who did not die suddenly or totally unexpectedly at home, as judged by the GP.ResultsWe conducted 205 interviews. Of these, 27 patients had at some point expressed a wish to receive a drug administered by a physician with the explicit intention to end life, that is, euthanasia. Thirteen of these formulated their requests explicitly and repeatedly, according to their GP. Compared with patients who expressed a wish but not an explicit/repeated request for euthanasia, those patients’ requests were more often documented (8 of 13 vs. 2 of 14; P = 0.01), and reiterated until their final days of life (6 of 13 vs. 0 of 14; P = 0.02). Five patients received euthanasia. For the other 22 patients, GPs gave different reasons for not acceding to the request, often related to criteria stipulated in the Belgian law on euthanasia, and sometimes related to personal reasons.ConclusionIt is not uncommon for patients to ask their GP for euthanasia, although explicit requests remain relatively rare. Requests tend to vary widely in form and content, and far more are expressed than complied with. For many GPs, the Belgian law on euthanasia serves as a guiding principle in this decision-making process, although in a minority of the cases, a GP’s personal opinion toward euthanasia seems to be decisive.