The role of 1H magnetic resonance spectroscopy in pre-operative evaluation for epilepsy surgery: A meta-analysis

PurposeWe aimed to assess the additional pre-operative value of 1H MRS in identifying the epileptogenic zone (EZ) for epilepsy surgery by performing a meta-analysis considering publications from 1992 to 2003.MethodsFrom an extensive computer and hand search 22 studies were included. For inclusion, studies had to report post-operative outcome and detailed diagnostic test results for each individual patient. Studies exclusively reporting on patients with brain tumors or on children were excluded.ResultsGreat heterogeneity among studies regarding methodological and technical aspects and concerning evaluation and interpretation of data was observed. Only patients with intractable temporal lobe epilepsy were presented. Sixty-four percent of all patients and 72% of patients with good outcome had an ipsilateral MRS abnormality concordant with the EZ. The positive predictive value of all patients with ipsilateral MRS abnormality for good outcome was 82%. An odds ratio weighted by inverse variance showed a 4.891 better chance of seizure free outcome [CI = 1.965–12.172; Q = 2.748; d.f. = 5; critical χ2-value = 11.07] in patients with an ipsilateral MRS abnormality when compared to patients with bilateral MRS abnormalities. Data for MRI-negative patients were conflicting. One study stressed a role for MRS in patients with bilateral hippocampal atrophy at MRI.ConclusionsMRS still remains a research tool with clinical potential. Our findings indicate the connection of ipsilateral MRS abnormality to good outcome. The ability for prediction of post-operative outcome may depend on the assessed population. Prospective studies limited to non-localized ictal scalp EEG or MRI-negative patients are required for validation of these data.