Genre analysis as a pre-instructional, instructional, and teacher development framework

• A student misinterpreted a statement in a journal article as the authors' attempt to “create a gap”.
• Further analysis indicates the overemphasis of “creating a gap” in teaching and learning.
• The incident shows how genre analysis facilitates students' learning of genre-specific features.
• It also shows how genre analysis can help EAP teachers to deepen their genre knowledge.

The framework of genre analysis described in Swales (1990) has become arguably the most influential one for analyzing EAP learners' target discourse and for developing learner-responsive EAP materials at the pre-instructional stage. What other roles can genre analysis play in EAP teaching and learning? In this paper, I present multiple excerpts from a student's genre analysis tasks and from my own analysis of the same journal article introduction that the student analyzed. I look closely at one ‘incident' in which the student interpreted a statement in the genre exemplar as the authors' attempt to “create a gap of study.” Elaborating on this ‘incident,’ I argue that the genre analysis framework conceptualized by Swales (1990) can function simultaneously at three interacting levels: as a framework for analyzing learners' target discourse at the pre-instructional stage, as a framework for guiding learners to learn EAP writing during instruction, and as a framework for EAP teachers to continuously deepen their genre knowledge and their knowledge of students' target genres. I conclude by proposing two future research directions: focusing on studying learners who use genre analysis to learn EAP and focusing on learners' real needs in genre analysis research projects.