Comparison Between Polymicrobial and Fungal Keratitis: Clinical Features, Risk Factors, and Outcome

PurposeTo compare the clinical features, risk factors, and outcome of polymicrobial keratitis with monomicrobial keratitis due to fungus.DesignRetrospective, comparative interventional case series.MethodsConsecutive cases of microbial keratitis with significant growth of more than 1 organism in culture and culture-proven fungal keratitis treated with natamycin alone were retrieved from the microbiology department. Complete success was defined as resolution of the infiltrate with scar formation on medical treatment, partial success as resolution following tissue adhesive application, and failure as inadequate response to medical therapy with increasing infiltrate size, corneal melting, and/or perforation necessitating therapeutic penetrating keratoplasty (PKP) or evisceration.ResultsThere were 34 eyes of 34 patients with polymicrobial keratitis and 60 cases of fungal keratitis. Compared to patients with fungal keratitis, patients with polymicrobial keratitis were significantly older (50.03 ± 9.81 years vs 42.79 ± 12.15 years, P = .0038), with larger infiltrates at presentation (61.8% vs 24.1%, P = .0007), a higher association with endophthalmitis (11.8% vs 0%, P = .03), previous history of corneal graft (20.6% vs 0%, P = .0012), and prior topical corticosteroid use (23.5% vs 5%, P = .019). In the polymicrobial group, a combination of bacteria and fungus was more frequently isolated (23, 67.6%), among which filamentous fungi (25, 39.1%) and coagulase-negative staphylococci (14, 21.9%) comprised a majority. Complete success was significantly lower in the polymicrobial group compared to the fungal keratitis group (39.3% vs 73.7%, P = .0045). In multivariate logistic regression analysis comparing factors affecting the outcome between the 2 groups, older age (P = .027) and ulcers larger than 6 mm (P = .001) at presentation adversely affected outcome.ConclusionsPolymicrobial keratitis with fungus and bacteria was more common and more challenging to treat, with a poorer outcome than fungal keratitis. Medical treatment may be effective; however, therapeutic PKP provided globe salvage at best. Early PKP may be advocated for larger ulcers at presentation.