Pavlovian valuation systems in learning and decision making

Environmental stimuli guide value-based decision making, but can do so through cognitive representation of outcomes or through general-incentive properties attributed to the cues themselves. We assert that these differences are conferred through the use of alternative associative structures differing in computational intensity. Using this framework, we review scientific evidence to discern the neural substrates of these assumed separable processes. We suggest that the contribution of the mesolimbic dopamine system to Pavlovian valuation is restricted to an affective system that is only updated through experiential feedback of stimulus-outcome pairing, whereas the orbitofrontal cortex contributes to an alternative system capable of inferential reasoning. Finally we discuss the interactions and convergence of these systems and their implications for decision making and its pathology.

► We apply a multiple systems framework to Pavlovian valuation. ► Recent evidence supports a selective role for dopamine in model-free Pavlovian valuation. ► Recent evidence supports a preferential role for the orbitofrontal cortex in model-based Pavlovian valuation. ► We discuss the implications of interaction between valuation systems for learning and decision making.