Aging and the reduction in fracture toughness of human dentin

An evaluation of the crack growth resistance of human coronal dentin was performed on tissue obtained from patients between ages 18 and 83. Stable crack extension was achieved over clinically relevant lengths (0≤a≤1mm) under Mode I quasi-static loading and perpendicular to the nominal tubule direction. Results distinguished that human dentin exhibits an increase in crack growth resistance with extension (i.e. rising RR-curve) and that there is a significant reduction in both the initiation (Ko) and plateau (Kp) components of toughness with patient age. In the young dentin (18≤age≤35) there was a 25% increase in the crack growth resistance from the onset of extension (Ko=1.34 MPa m0.5) to the maximum or “plateau” toughness (Kp=1.65 MPa m0.5). In comparison, the crack growth resistance of the old dentin (55≤age) increased with extension by less than 10% from Ko=1.08 MPa m0.5 to Kp=1.17 MPa m0.5. In young dentin toughening was achieved by a combination of inelastic deformation of the mineralized collagen matrix and microcracking of the peritubular cuffs. These mechanisms facilitated further toughening via the development of unbroken ligaments of tissue and posterior crack-bridging. Microstructural changes with aging decreased the capacity for near-tip inelastic deformation and microcracking of the tubules, which in turn suppressed the formation of unbroken ligaments and the degree of extrinsic toughening.