Performance evaluation with portfolio holdings information

This paper surveys recent academic research that uses portfolio holdings to evaluate the performance of an asset manager. These approaches mitigate the benchmark-choice problem of Roll (1978), as well as providing a much more precise attribution of the sources of manager returns. Although originally developed with U.S. data, recent papers have applied these approaches to European, Asian, and Australian equity managers. All surveyed approaches can be integrated into the Brinson, Hood, and Beebower (1986) attribution method, if we allow the composition of the benchmark portfolio to evolve through time according to the observed portfolio holdings of an asset manager.